Liverpool Rumours Member Posts

 

Ecogsi's Profile

Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded
Correct Score Competition:

Not entered
Correct Score Competition
Flat Out Racing:

Not played Flat Out Racing


No Profile Picture uploaded

Team:


Where from:


Favourite player:


Best team moment:


Interests:


Timezone:




Ecogsi's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To Ecogsi's Posts

 

 

To Ecogsi's last 5 banter posts

 

To Ecogsi's last 5 rumour replies

 

To Ecogsi's last 5 banter replies

 

Ecogsi has no Rumours Posts

 

 

Ecogsi's banter posts with other poster's replies to Ecogsi's banter posts

 

18 Sep 2024 17:56:22
Agree with the praise for grav, he played really well. Great result away from home especially after going behind early.

Having said all that there's definitely room for improvement. Felt an extra pass in front of goal would have led to couple of tapins for gakpo and slob. Very disappointed in how open we were second half, interesting to hear slot talk about risk vs reward and hopefull we adapt to keeping the ball when we're winning games instead of going for more goals and forcing the play.

Ecogsi

1.) 18 Sep 2024 18:31:23
Hate to say it but we need someone a bit better than Jota upfront to properly challenge. I know this now means he’ll go on a scoring streak - which is fine - but I thought he was poor again last night as well as against Forest. Not sure what we need to do to get the best out of him….


2.) 18 Sep 2024 19:05:18
Jota is a strange player, he can be lethal in the box so he’s great to have around, but often his first touch and build up play is poor. His attitude is excellent though, and his work rate.

Combine him and Nunez and you’d have the perfect player! Slot must think he’s more reliable than Darwin, and you can understand why but it’s a shame the coaches can’t help improve his all round game,


3.) 18 Sep 2024 19:21:53
Jota is who he is. He's a 1 in 3 forward, decent but not world class. He's probably not a player that should be starting week in week out for a team that's challenging for the league and champions league.


4.) 18 Sep 2024 19:25:10
Just saw Arne's Secret Forward line for Bournemouth Saturday:

"Salah-KONATE-VVD-Gakpo"


5.) 18 Sep 2024 19:36:36
Gets dropped for Nunez and used s a super sub for a few games,


6.) 18 Sep 2024 20:28:52
I was saying in the transfer window that if we are playing a 4 - 2 - 3 -1 the “1” should have been our priority signing. Jota is a natural scorer but he has his defects. Nunez runs around a lot and, apparently, causes havoc. However, it seems he has problems with a lack of anticipation and awareness (offside way too often) and his finishing, to be charitable, is erratic.


7.) 18 Sep 2024 23:55:32
Right now id like to see Jota and Nunez get 45 mins each in matches. As the poster above said, they both bring different facets to the game along with high workrate. It would be a nightmare for opposition defenders having to contain their different styles in the same match.

{Ed025's Note - with them 2 DE its their team mates who need to get used to their different styles mate, 2 headless chickens..


8.) 19 Sep 2024 04:24:17
I’d be tempted to play Gakpo on the left, Diaz on the right (of the 3) and put Mo up top.


9.) 19 Sep 2024 07:15:59
That would be the front 3 I would like to see as well wdw. Keep salah as close to goal as possible would be my thinking.


10.) 19 Sep 2024 09:55:23
If Nunez plays it’s ball through middle or over and crosses in to the box but do they play to his strengths no……as soon as he’s been subbed they start doing it……why? Don’t get it me. He also should be allowed a run of games not a sub appearance here and there and fans on his back when he doesn’t do anything in his 15minute spell. I swear now if he was at another club he’d be firing. Only after a good run of games can he be really assessed and for me he’s never had it. And imagine if all those post he hit were goals haha.


11.) 19 Sep 2024 15:17:56
I've been saying this for a long time. Jota is deadly in the box BUT if he can't get those chances to score and is not playing his best or offering anything else then, this is what you get.

Vs Milan, he had a good chance of either scoring or squaring to Gakpo for a tap in and he just fired it wide. That's a guy struggling for confidence.

Maybe it's time for Nunez to start to see what he can bring to the team cos we all know had Darwin not even hit the target nor square the ball in the see situation, the knives would be out. Just my take.


12.) 19 Sep 2024 20:37:06
Diaz left, salah centre, chiesa right.


 

 

30 Aug 2024 21:28:24
I'm really happy with the balance of the squad, helped massively with the injury free squad we currently have. No doubt slot will use the first half of the season to evaluate the players. I hope he's ruthless moving forward and doesn't allow players to get comfortable. Chiesa is a shrewd bit of business if you ask me. Really hopeful for the new era.

Ecogsi

 

 

17 May 2024 16:59:53
Not sure if it’s been asked already. Looking for opinions on this season? I’m Torn between the Feeling it’s been an absolute anticlimax or it’s been a decent season with a trophy and coming 3rd in the league is a true representation of where we’re at as a squad. Or has klopp set such high standards that 3rd and a trophy leaves a feeling of under achieving?! Heads a mess!

Ecogsi

1.) 17 May 2024 17:36:28
Big anticlimax.


2.) 17 May 2024 17:40:36
All of the above.


3.) 17 May 2024 18:22:35
My feeling is that it's slightly disappointing at the most, but hardly an absolute anticlimax. We were still in it with 5-6 games remaining, but I think we just happened to have our anual dip in form at the wrong time. After last year's performance and the fact that we kept chalking up the points while playing very well at times and very poorly at other times this season, I will admit I had hopes that we could cross the line first. But fine it didn't happen and that's football. After all, we still won a Cup (the Mickey Mouse one as some call it on here) and Klopp righted the ship from what was definitely a disastrous year last year. And he's leaving behind a rejuvenated squad with plenty of youngsters eager to prove themselves, so I have hope under the new manager.


4.) 17 May 2024 20:22:47
A good season, much better than last, but nothing more than good.


5.) 17 May 2024 21:54:37
The Europa Cup was there for us to win. Getting turned over by Atlanta was sickening but what can you do?‍♂️. It hasn’t been a bad season but wasn’t great either.


6.) 17 May 2024 22:23:59
Overall Arsenal and City have been better than us
Yes i am disappointed we had a opportunity to win more in Klopps final season however we are giving our new manager Champions league football and a solid foundation.


7.) 17 May 2024 23:13:23
This is the type of season everyone predicted we could have based on the rebuild so we have essentially, met expectations, IMO. Could we have done better? Obviously yes BUT at the end of the day, many of us did not think we could challenge for the title let alone win it going in and based on the way the season played out, we were right. On to a new era set to begin with Arne Slot next season.


8.) 17 May 2024 23:18:39
Missed opportunity and I don’t think we’ve played well as a team.

Bradley was an exciting high point and Danns and Koumas were great in their cameos.


9.) 18 May 2024 00:12:33
A poor season. Underperformed.


10.) 18 May 2024 07:29:21
I am a glass half full guy…. I think it has been a good season. The biggest disappointment for me was us not making Europa league final, we (alongside leverkusen) were the best team and lost our heads in that first Atalanta game.
I think to win the league with all the changes to the team, injuries and performance/ slump of last season was alway going to be a step too far.
Overall, I would give the season 7/ 10! The league cup final was a memorable game fitting for Klopps final season.
Bradley and quansah really impress me and actually I really enjoy Gomez as the inverted left back as I think it helps to give us control.
Excited to see how Slot approaches his tactics.


11.) 18 May 2024 07:51:50
LTO I really don’t believe you had us down at the start of the season winning the league. Just don’t believe it with the midfield rebuild we had, the only thing we’ve fallen short of is winning europa league we should have won that with the level of players we have.

{Ed001's Note - if anyone had said at the start of the season we would finish 3rd, win the League Cup and get so far in the Europa, I think 99% of us would have been delighted. It is just that the way the season transpired, the only reason we fell away from the title and failed to reach the FA Cup and Europa League final is down to our own failings, that makes it feel so bad. What makes it worse is that Klopp is partly to blame for us not still being in for the quadruple, when we are all so thankful for what he has brought to us. But the good thing is that now nothing can take away from Anfield giving Klopp the send off he deserves, as the game is a dead rubber for us. So we can just enjoy a giant farewell party and I have no doubt that we will all be in floods of tears saying goodbye to a true great of the club. One of very few men that truly deserve to be called a legend.}


12.) 18 May 2024 08:28:31
The rebuild excuse doesn’t wash with me. I would guess City and Arsenal purchased as many first team players last Summer as we did, don’t hear them making the same excuse.


13.) 18 May 2024 09:26:12
LTO123, Underperformed, based on what? Did you have us challenging for the title at the start of the season where we didn't even have a DM and many were losing their ship when the Caicedo deal collapsed?

If the answer is no then, you cannot come on here and say we underperformed IF you yourself didn't think we would perform anyway. Sorry, that dog ain't going to hunt. Talk about having it all your own way. Give over, man.


14.) 18 May 2024 09:27:04
Yes but we'd been miles away from Ars/ Man City the season before Irish, we've closed that gap considerably. Im with Ed in that if you had offerd me 3rd and a trophy i would have jumped on it. I would have bit your hand off for 4th.


15.) 18 May 2024 09:45:10
@IR, that's cos both teams are way further ahead in their development than we were going into this season so comparing us with them is already dishonest hece, flawed from the off. I know, shocking.

Also, did you think we could challenge for the title going into the season? If the answer is no (which it is cos nobody on this forum (including you) said so at the time) then, don't start with the "excuses" nonsense cos even YOU believed we would not challenge for the title, let alone win it. Meaning? Even you believed we were in a rebuild at the time and no amount of hindsight or "whatever washes with you, me or whoever" will change that.

Oh and guess what? We will STILL be in a rebuild next season with Slot as well, and both City and Arsenal will STILL be ahead of us in their development going in. I propose you get used to that very quickly, as well. No excuses here, sunny. Just facts.


16.) 18 May 2024 10:11:21
It's been a good season; maybe even a very good one.
We were behind City and Arsenal in terms of quality last season and we have significantly narrowed that gap. When you consider that we lost three experienced midfielders and had to replace them adds to it, too.
I didn't expect us to challenge for the title this season so it's not been a big disappointment. Don't get me wrong, I was annoyed with those few weeks when everything went to pot but if you look at the season overall it's been a good one.


17.) 18 May 2024 09:35:31
Totally with Ed001 here.

Start of season to end of season - it was brilliant (i. e. if you'd said at the start of the season, given we finished 5th last time etc) .

However, in the last 3 months there have been massive highs and lows.

On balance a season that is a bare minimum for our club, but it could have been so much more and it was in our hands.

Glass is neither half full or half empty.

The glass is just half.


18.) 18 May 2024 11:00:09
@Ed01 - absolutely 100% spot on with your comments. Great summary of the season and the status of Klopp in the history of the club. He has the same aura of man management about him that Shanks had - there’s no higher praise.


19.) 18 May 2024 11:34:58
The main disappointment for me is the Europa League. We should’ve at least made the final the minute Leverkusen were put on the other side of the draw. Every other team in the competition was a team we should be beating comfortably.

FA Cup and Prem were never givens as we’d have had to have seen off City in both and they’re bordering on untouchable right now. We should’ve got to the final in FA cup as well though (as United and Coventry were the teams in our way) and really we should’ve taken the league to the final day from the position we were in going into the home game against Palace.

It’s a shame but if you remove all context, on the face of it, we’ve had a decent season and won a trophy. Let’s just enjoy the last game with Klopp rather than fret about what could’ve been.


20.) 18 May 2024 13:27:18
Regardless of what anyone said or expectations were in Aug 2023 it has zero bearing on the fact that with 7 league games to go we were joint top of the league.

The squad did well and could say over achieved to get us into that position but losing to Palace and Everton and drawing with Utd, West Ham and Villa over the next 6 fixtures has absolutely nothing to do with rebuilds or expectations 10 moths ago.

We went out of 3 tournaments in a matter of weeks. If that was anyone else we would say they bottled it.

Overall 3rd and league cup is a good season but we could have and should have had a better one considering where we were 5-6 weeks ago.

With a new manager coming in next season 3rd and a trophy might be as good as it gets for the foreseeable.


21.) 18 May 2024 13:50:14
MKS, I can agree with you and others on the EL topic. That was really bad. it hurt the way we went out esp. in that first half where Klopp put out the lineup signalling to the oppo. (a very good one at that) that like, "Yeah, we ain't ready, bro". It was what it was and I can understand the frustration cos I was and still am with the way we didn't address our issues (as Ed01 sid, that's on Klopp and the staff) to give us a better chance to finish with more trophies.


Like you and all that being said, I would not trade a damn thing for any of the days Kloppo was our manager. Nothing at all.

"Celebration Time, Come on! "

Hopefully, Cool And The Gang will be at Anfield tmrw, lol.


22.) 18 May 2024 14:57:11
Oli
Getting his excuses already for next season. Rebuild still in process.
Please point me in the direction where I said we were in a rebuild? Embarrassing.


23.) 18 May 2024 19:51:11
Irish exactly. 6 weeks ago we were being told that Arsenal and City would slip up first.

Apparently Arsenal can’t score goals and City can only win titles when they’re leading the league.

We shot our shot for the title and came up short over the last 6 games.

What people’s expectations were 8 months ago or hindsight have nothing to do with it.


24.) 19 May 2024 02:03:20
JK, maybe being in contention with six games to go is an achievement. For me, it is.
How can people's expectations from eight months ago have nothing to do with it over a full season?
What are people's expectations based upon? Who are the people?
I didn't expect us to challenge but as the season went on I was pleasantly surprised. But as the season went on I saw the midfield replacements were not going to win us a league, the front three wasn't the quality of the one that won us the League and the defence was now, dare I say it, in transition.
If the other CL contenders were not so bad it might not have looked so bad for us.
United, Spurs, Newcastle and Chelsea are not even in contention on the last day of the season.


25.) 19 May 2024 10:27:55
Rigsby I’ve sold in a post above that being there in the first place was an achievement.

But I doubt Klopp and the players went into those games caring about what posters in a banter sites predictions were 8 months ago.

Klopps leaving a very good squad behind but for me he was the glue that kept it all together. Next season we will still have a very good squad but we won’t have the Klopp factor.

I don’t think Slot will be a failure but I just don’t expect us to be challenging like we have been under Jurgen.

6 games ago we had a chance to win the league and ultimately we came up short with some very poor results and performances.


 

 

23 Aug 2022 14:39:04
Have we become predictable? Are other teams exploiting our high line and defensive weakness at right back? I understand our high line and high press has worked brilliantly but for the sake of dropping off 20 yards when we lose possession to avoid being caught flat must be a no brainer.

Ecogsi

1.) 23 Aug 2022 15:10:11
Yes, simple answer. I’m sure it can be fixed but would rather it sooner than later!


2.) 23 Aug 2022 15:22:06
This is going to sound like a contradiction but here goes.

I love Klopp and I definitely think he is the best man to fix this current dilemma. However I think he is quite stubborn and if he is to fix it he will do it his way which will involve continuing with the high line.

Not once did he try and get rid of the high line when we had Kabak, Rhys Williams or Phillips as our centre half’s and them 3 would struggle to outrun a parked car.


3.) 23 Aug 2022 15:36:24
Jurgens fellow countryman Albert Einstein sums up Jurgens stubbornness quite succinctly (brief and clearly expressed) .

"Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results". (Mental Pressures in other words) .


4.) 23 Aug 2022 15:45:09
Not to be contrarian but the high line is not the issue. It's the midfield that is not functioning properly and the forwards having to receive more difficult/ riskier passes resulting in possession lost, and the inevitable gaping middle third that poor Fabinho has to patrol on his own.

Just for nuance, Virgil, Trent and Robbo are stinking at the moment too.


5.) 23 Aug 2022 18:35:39
If the forwards could convert more than 1 of the 20 odd shots per game it might ease the pressure on the midfield and defence.


6.) 23 Aug 2022 19:00:59
Fly is right. The high line has always been a risk but the midfield being ineffective getting the ball to feet and being creative give the opposition the confidence to press and leave faster players up top to exploit the high line. Yeah VVD hasn’t started playing this season yet but the root cause of the current issues is not the defence. IMO anyway.


7.) 23 Aug 2022 19:19:14
Oh mane mane in fairness mate the chances last night and the other 2 games were mostly pot shots.

Diaz comes inside every time so he’s becoming easier to defend against unless he pulls out another Palace Worldie and Salah is being doubled up on every time we get the ball. Bobby isn’t dragging any centre half’s with him and could have been man marked by Rashford last night.


8.) 23 Aug 2022 19:50:52
I think he can be stubborn and too loyal. Some players still at the club should have been shipped out several years ago. We all know who they are.


9.) 23 Aug 2022 19:50:52
I think he can be stubborn and too loyal. Some players still at the club should have been shipped out several years ago. We all know who they are.


10.) 23 Aug 2022 20:41:05
We can talk about chances created but we aren't creating great chances. I don't recall last night thinking "we have to score there". Even Salah's goal De Gea should have saved it. United but for poor finishing could have scored 4. Virgil so casual against Fulham for the pen, he watched Zaha score and last night stood like a statue for 3-4 seconds and could have easily closed down Sancho and even blocked the shot, just like against Zaha last week. Mitrovic had an identical header at the weekend to the one he scored against us and the keeper palmed it away. Trent hasn't learned to look over his shoulder even after the CL Final mistake but equally Virgil responsible too for doing the hands behind the back statue impersonation "defending" Valverde. Trent got done by Mitrovic and same against Palace and now United. Also didn't track Foden in the charity shield for their goal. He's having a terrible season defensively and for the first time I'd say no way is he looking like the best english right back.


 

 

 

Ecogsi's rumour replies

 

Click To View This Thread

30 Oct 2024 14:16:36
The truth will come out sooner or later. I believe he told the club he’d be leaving on a free a while ago. Real Madrid been in his ear for a while.

Ecogsi

 

 

Click To View This Thread

17 May 2024 16:47:40
Good when fit but made of glass.

Ecogsi

 

 

Click To View This Thread

29 Mar 2024 10:31:00
So surprised he’s willing to stay in Germany for another season if he wins the league. I really thought the stars had aligned for Alonso to manage us before inevitably moving on to his dream job at Madrid.

Ecogsi

 

 

Click To View This Thread

31 Aug 2023 12:37:36
Edd, who’s you like to see us sign to replace salah now or next summer?

Ecogsi

{Ed002's Note - I think Marcus Edwards would be a great option, but it won't be him.}


 

 

Click To View This Thread

30 Aug 2023 21:25:25
Paulinha would have been a great signing for our engine room.

Ecogsi

 

 

 

Ecogsi's banter replies

 

Click To View This Thread

03 Oct 2024 22:38:48
Hopeful doak gets a chance with us, the rest will fall short for varying reasons.

Ecogsi

 

 

Click To View This Thread

03 Oct 2024 22:35:49
Just to get this straight, are we saying “the club has not offered a local lad that has come through the clubs system, established himself in the team, developed into the one of the best footballing right backs in Europe (was bang average defensively, although looks to be improving this season) and are happy for him to go on a free?!

The cynic in me says that the club can’t be that stupid and they’ve been told he won’t sign a contract and will be leaving on free (to real)

I’ll be absolutely gutted and disgusted if either are true!

Ecogsi

 

 

Click To View This Thread

02 Oct 2024 17:39:58
Don’t blame uefa, fifa or the respective league associations for burn out. Yes there’s too many competitions, yes they all want to squeeze the final drop of money out of football but look no further than the clubs that employ them.

They have every opportunity to rest and rotate. The top clubs with the best players have the fullest squads to alleviate player burnout. That’s where the discussion should start, clubs have a duty of care as employers to protect their employees. Yes this should start with uefa and fifa but they don’t give a monkeys about anything other than money and profit!

Ecogsi

 

 

Click To View This Thread

30 Sep 2024 17:44:48
Spot on review, agree with all points, especially not playing well and winning.

The game as a whole was absolutely awful, it’s very difficult to up a game when it starts off so poorly.

Was hoping to see slsalah come off for chiesa to add some legs out wide, salah did look tired.

As for vvd. I don’t remember Hansen other than the highlight reels but vvd for me is the best all round centre half I’ve ever seen. At his best he has no weaknesses and makes the game look easy, at times it looks like he barely gets out of 4th gear. What a player he’s been for us.

Ecogsi

 

 

Click To View This Thread

27 Sep 2024 18:34:57
Endo will be an important squad player for us this season. His style of play definitely suites certain games.

Ecogsi

 

 





Change Consent