18 Nov 2026 06:12:34
Question for Ed001 please. It's well documented that you are a big fan of Noah Sadiki.

Do you think Lamine Camara is a similar type of player? If so, what do you prefer about Sadiki? Is it just that you have seen more of him? Or is it that he is proven and settled in the PL? Or do you think he is a better player based on having watched them both? Thanks in advance!

{Ed001's Note - I have seen very very little of Camara, just highlights mainly.}


1.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 06:58:37
Proven and Settled in PL is definetely an advantage.


2.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 07:45:54
They are not actually very similar players. Camara is an all action 8 who is very involved in the general play for Monaco, he even takes most of their set pieces (or at least he did when I saw him play for them last year). He enjoys the tackling/breaking up play/pressing (sometimes a bit too eager chasing the ball and getting pulled out of position) side of the game, but he is also a very good passer of the ball, I often saw him drop between the center halves to get on the ball in the build up, he has a deceptively wide range of passing as well as being a very good carrier of the ball, wins a lot of fouls in the center circle using his body to shield the ball too. He is also capable of making quick decisions when he gets on the ball to switch it out to the wings, to play it quickly through the lines.

I would say that while he shows qualities that we could use if he were to be converted into a midfielder who is instructed to stay behind the ball rather than run ahead of the ball, it's not a straightforward ask because he's not what you would call a natural 'defensive midfielder' despite showing tenacity and aggression for the role.

Sadiki is a much simpler player on the ball since Xhaka is the one who advances the ball, Sadiki can protect the ball and he is very athletic and strong, can carry too but he is not at all what you would call a passer. He would be much closer between the two to being a 'defensive midfielder' since his job is primarily to be a front-footed presser, with Xhaka doing the progression and Sadiki doing the legwork.

That's what I can glean from limited experience watching the two players anyway. Probably somebody with much more insight could weigh in.


3.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 08:48:24
Patrik, that's a pretty accurate & comprehensive overview.


4.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 09:22:09
Sadiki sounds much closer to the Fabinho profile than Camara. Of course Fabinho had other skills that perhaps were not used as much, but with Henderson and Wijnaldum being far more mobile, he sat back usually and acted the "destroyer" type most of the time. Now it's a question of what Iraola wants exactly given the midfield players we already have.

{Ed001's Note - Sadiki is nothing like that. He is more like N'Golo Kante, covering everywhere at once, somehow. He is by far and away the most mobile player in the current Premier League.}


5.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 09:41:30
Okay, Ed001, I was going by PatrikBurgher's description. I've never watched him play, or don't recall ever seeing him play.

{Ed001's Note - half the time I am having to check that was him there because a second before he was in a completely different place.}


6.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 10:53:42
Sadiki is a super mobile and athletic player, he's an aggressive ball winner and not a 'light house' shielding the defence like Fab was, though Fab sat like that because he was instructed to do so. It's just that Sadiki isn't somebody you expect to contribute a lot going forward, fizzing the ball through the lines or spraying the ball or anything, that's just not his game, whereas Camara can and does do those things for Monaco (whether he can do those things regularly in the prem is another matter).

Fab was a really mobile player btw, it's just that he didn't need to cover massive amounts of space for us regularly. When he looked stretched later on in his Liverpool career he had lost his legs, but that doesn't mean he never had them.


7.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 11:34:00
Defensively, athletically and even height (both only 5'8), there's not much between them.

However, Camara is better with the ball. He's as good as Macca is technically.

Yes, in his role at Monaco he likes to go hunting for the ball, because the coach wants him to and he's really effective at it. He's often the player of the match when they play PSG.


8.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 11:53:23
Crazy and lucky how any player or manager the club is linked to certain posters never seem to have missed their games.

Leverkusen, Feyenoord, Diomande, Camara, Newcastle, Bournemouth, PSG and now Sunderland.

Must be a nightmare if any of these teams kick off same time as Liverpool.


9.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 10:44:55
Agree with Ed001 - Kante is the name that I was thinking of too. "The lungs of the team", never standing still, doing the graft.

Being Premier League proven and Sunderland struggling are two massive ticks in big boxes for me. We should be contacting Sunderland.

{Ed001's Note - spot on Ron.


10.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 12:31:06
I don't claim to have watched either player extensively, I've seen Camara about 2 or 3 times but never really paid much attention to him. That could also mean he didn't stand out as a good player.

Sadiki though, I really don't get it. I've generally only watched him if Sunderland are playing us or one of our rivals but he looks a bit average to me. Not great on the ball, rash in the tackle, too small to be aerially dominant, positionally unaware.

He runs around a lot and looks busy but how affective is he really? Perhaps defensive midfielders are not my thing because other than Rodri and of course the mighty Trey Nyoni I can't really think of one I like.

{Ed025's Note - i really like Trey RSO, but please dont put him in the same sentence as Rodri mate...well not yet..


11.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 13:23:03
JK, to be fair, when you have needed a defensive-minded midfielder for 4 years, you tend to watch them play in admiration at other clubs. :)


12.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 13:12:19
Inesita maybe ed25? ?.

{Ed025's Note - in his dreams Digger.. :)


13.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 13:19:15
Ed's and others? What's the consensus on Ngal'ayel Mukau? From what I've seen he looks an absolute beast and would suit us down to the ground.

{Ed001's Note - not seen him play, sorry.}


14.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 14:32:49
"Proven and Settled in PL is definetely an advantage.".

No, it isn't, tbh. We have seen plenty of players who were "Proven and Settled in the PL" only to come in here and stink up the joint.

Ian Graham said that BR was addicted to this talking point hence why he signed Benteke, for the disaster we would later know him to be. Yet he also signed Bobbie in that same window (who he allegedly did not want because he wasn't "Proven in the Prem") and we all know how that worked out. There's a lot more where that came from, btw.

For me whoever it is we get (and from wherever it is we get him/them) needs to be able to do the job asked of him/them and hopefully, they can come good.

Being proven and settled in the PL is irrelevant to me based on past experiences and is no longer the flex people think it is.


15.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 14:58:35
Chema Andres looks a very good player for Brighton, Rio, think he will probably prove to be another excellent buy for them.


16.) 18 Nov 2026
18 Nov 2026 16:25:08
Fly I don't know where people find the hours mate.

If some were to believed they living 40 hour days.

Personally I think they like to use Ai and probably couldn't pick the players they post monologues about out of a suspect line up.


17.) 18 Nov 2026

18 Nov 2026 17:52:29
I spend so much time nit picking our own players, I honestly haven't got time to watch players of other teams.