01 Jun 2016 12:41:14
If Reina is good enuf to come back, i do not see why Agger can't, surely he is at least good enough from our bench if he is deemed good enuf for AC Milan 1st team.

1.) 01 Jun 2016
01 Jun 2016 12:54:04
There is no bigger fan of Daniel Agger on this site than me, however is injuries and his age tells me he would not be able to his league anymore.

In Italy, he will get more time on the ball and it will be a lot less physical.

I absolutely love Agger and how he played, but he won't be coming back.

2.) 01 Jun 2016
01 Jun 2016 12:55:50
Love agger to bits. But ac Milan aren't the team they once were.

3.) 01 Jun 2016
01 Jun 2016 13:03:04
On that logic shall we re sign Traore and draft Bolo Zenden out of retirement?

4.) 01 Jun 2016
01 Jun 2016 14:16:50
Although I said we shouldn't bring him back Dave, how do Traore and Zenden come under the same logic?

Pepe and Agger are both still playing and were icons to a lot of fans at Anfield, so both could easily return.

However like I said, as much as I loved him, I don't think Agger should.

5.) 01 Jun 2016
01 Jun 2016 14:52:31
We would be going backwards the only past players I would have back are Suarez and Alonso . can't think of anyone else maybe macherano. time we moved on now and let klopp stamp his own authority with his own buys (in klopp we trust)

6.) 01 Jun 2016
01 Jun 2016 15:37:12
Pepe kept 18 clean sheets in 44 games last season, conceding just 34 goals. Ludacris to suggest he would be going backwards. He is a much better competition for Karius than Mignolet or Bogdan. Last season was arguably the best he's ever had actually.

Agger would be a good back up and excellent option to replace Toure not only in the squad but in the dressing room. he isn't better than Lovren or Matip though so wouldn't start.

Alonso is world class and would walk into any team in world football.

Torres is still clearly a top player. Anybody denying that is in lala land as he is first choice for Athletico Madrid who are probably in the top 5 teams in Europe.

Mascherano is also blatantly a world class player still as he is the first name on the team sheet for both Barcelona and Argentina.

Gerrard if it wasn't for his excessive player power would also improve our squad based on footballing ability. It is the negative affect he has off the pitch that makes him not worth considering.

Suarez, well if I need to argue his ability it's ridiculous.

I am in no way suggesting we sign any of these players. We should be building for the future with young players Klopp can mould into his own style of play. Not signing players in their 30's based on sentiment.

To deny that any of these players would be an improvement on what we have, is just blatantly lying to yourself though. We don't have to be derogatory towards our former heroes just because we are in denial that the club made a mistake letting them go.

Suarez excluded the players I've listed were the cornerstones of our best side we've had in 2 decades. The only guy missing is Carragher and that's because he retired. Why slag them off? Irrespective of how some of them left, they are all still good enough for Premier League football, and all still better than at least our second string players.

I agree we should be looking forward, but that doesn't mean we need to slag off former greats.

7.) 01 Jun 2016
01 Jun 2016 15:53:52
Who is slagging off any former greats. i see everyone agreeing that they loved the players when they were here and still do but they get old and decline, it happens.
Reina is not the answer to any question, unless that is to come sit on the bench as a back up, Karius has been bought with the view to being our number 1 asap, otherwise ward would just have been kept as sub keeper. No Reina coming in and expecting game time ahead of him.
Agger barely played in his final seasons because of injury, I doubt he would have improved by getting older.

8.) 01 Jun 2016
01 Jun 2016 17:24:51
Kopdogs

Reina has been on top form at Naples whole last season. Y on earth would he be second to Karius? What's the age of Peter Czech?

All this over expectations on Karius is frightning.

9.) 01 Jun 2016
01 Jun 2016 18:56:13
I didn't say he would be. I said the plan will be for Karius to be our number, he will need games to get there why bring in reina to take that game time. mignolet has just signed a new contract. And it will be unlikely he will be leaving. Although he is certainly not perfect he gets far too much stick and is still a decent keeper. Karius and migs will battle it out for number 1 this year. Is Reina ment to replace Mignolet? That would be a downgrade in my opinion. Clean sheets? How many has Mignolet had each season and he is apparently terrible playing behind the apparent worse defenders we have ever had.

10.) 01 Jun 2016
01 Jun 2016 19:08:37
We don`t need any of them, end of.

11.) 01 Jun 2016
01 Jun 2016 19:26:20
Unless he's declined significantly as a footballer since he was here, Agger would walk into our team. He was able to do everything Sakho does but with less mistakes. And he was much more of a leader at the back too.

Problem is he's quite likely to miss half the season with various injuries which then disrupts the defence as he comes in and out of the team. And with Sakho probably suspended for the start of the season, and not exactly having a spotless injury record either, it's too much disruption to the backline. Center back is not a place where you want to chop and change regularly.

It's all hypothetical anyway, neither him or Reina are coming back.

12.) 01 Jun 2016
01 Jun 2016 19:43:03
Torres? Jesus.

13.) 01 Jun 2016
01 Jun 2016 19:43:23
Some may look at them as a step back, I personally wouldn't, they're far from past it. Reina is still a fantastic keeper, better then Mignolet atleast, Agger is Agger. an ultimate beast, if he was still at Liverpool i'd imagine him as a starter most games.

Although as has been previously stated, the problem about Agger is the injuries, unfortunately that would be concerning enough to not resign him. either way neither of them are going to return anyway.

14.) 01 Jun 2016
01 Jun 2016 23:26:04
They all left the club - some due to reasons that had little to do with their performances and form at the time. I wouldn't have any back if it were up to me.

15.) 02 Jun 2016
02 Jun 2016 05:03:01
i'd have agger back anytime. because he is liverpool through and through and he definitely would work magic under klopp. More so we need a leader, a fan fav, Someone who can push the team when it needs that push. agger to replace kolo anytime and everytime. maybe its sentimental but that is exactly how our manager is.