04 Oct 2018 17:34:12
Ed 001, if it is believed that Hummels position at Bayern may he coming to an end.
Do Liverpool have or shown any interest? Do you see him as a viable option and would you want him?

Many thanks

red deano YNWA.

{Ed001's Note - no interest that I am aware of, though he does speak glowingly about Klopp so on a free if Matip or Lovren were to leave it may be possible. Personally I would think he was not worth looking at as he is poor at defending.}


1.) 04 Oct 2018
04 Oct 2018 20:52:39
Ed001, isn’t that a trait of the modern day defender these days?

{Ed001's Note - not many as awful as him to be fair. Great on the ball but god awful as a defender and about as quick as an hour with Michael McIntyre. Well, maybe not as slow as that, as there is little worse than an hour with McIntyre. McIntyre is the comedy equivalent of a cheesegrater to the private parts.}


2.) 05 Oct 2018
05 Oct 2018 10:13:50
My favorite comedian McIntyre.

{Ed001's Note - is that a bad joke? Maybe one of his?}


3.) 05 Oct 2018
05 Oct 2018 11:15:12
One of the few players I disagree with you on Ed001, I've always found Hummels to be a good defender who reads the game well. He's slow but his positional sense is excellent. Great player to have when breaking down defensive teams or launching a counter attack. That said he's been particularly poor in the air in his last couple seasons which is strange as it used to be one of his biggest strengths. I find it hard to imagine him moving to Liverpool but I think he'd be an upgrade on Lovren or Matip. Would prefer to develop Gomez though.

McIntyre is awful. He's about as funny as my Granddad Hugh, who while hilarious, has been dead for several years.

{Ed001's Note - his positional sense is ok, but the speed of the game means he often can't get into position as he is too slow. His tackling is weak and he has no spring in his legs any more due to injuries. He is finished at the top level by the looks of it, sadly.}


4.) 05 Oct 2018
05 Oct 2018 11:29:10
His joke about the spices is absolutely hilarious.

{Ed001's Note - enough about Hummels, what about McIntyre?}


5.) 05 Oct 2018
05 Oct 2018 11:57:18
Hope that isn’t the case and that if it is he enjoys something of a renaissance. It wasn’t too long ago that it seemed as though Rakitic’s legs were gone and now look at him. Either way a move to Liverpool isn’t happening.


6.) 05 Oct 2018
05 Oct 2018 18:12:54
Ed001, I share your views on Mcintyre entirely. I just don't get him. Had funnier visits to the dentist. Lee Mack, Milton Jones more my cup of tea.

{Ed001's Note - I just don't get why people like the squeaky voiced tit.}


7.) 05 Oct 2018
05 Oct 2018 18:23:36
I get angry watching him. How he sells out large arenas, God only knows. He just comes across as an upper class twat.

{Ed002's Note - Hummels won't be moving to Liverpool.}


8.) 05 Oct 2018
05 Oct 2018 19:53:23
Thanks for your thoughts Ed001, its appreciated.

red deano YNWA.


9.) 06 Oct 2018
06 Oct 2018 08:23:25
Funniest thing involving McIntyre was his appearance on BBC Test Match special. He’d been waiting to get on as a guest and was talking glowingly about how it was s lifetime ambition.
It was absolute car crash listening as all his “humour” went down like a lead balloon and it culminated in Agnew saying “is this supposed to be funny”? 😂😂

I guess nodding your head very quickly doesn’t really work on radio 😄.